Love your blog, hate your registration system - An open letter to Dylan at Mboffin.com
By Chris on Mar 30, 2007 | In Noteworthy blogs | 2 feedbacks »
Preface:
I've been paying attention to the Mboffin blog since I discovered it way back in September of '05. I have often wanted to comment on the content, but Dylan's blogware requires registration in order to comment. This is a chronicle of my attempts to register and the frustration that it has caused. As you'll see below, alerting him to the problems is actually the greater problem. I'm posting this here hoping that he finds it via an ego search, or perhaps you know him...
Dear MBoff,
Hello, love your blog and want to comment many times. BUT...
Tried to register once like a year ago. Used the name Xangelusx. Either I entered the email address wrong or something else went kludgey, but I was never able to log in. To compound matters, your contact form was only open to registered users, so I was SOL.
Now, love the FNE post. Want to tell you as much. I'm adopting it whole heartedly for that matter (I never ever LOLed, really. Though I did FNE at your FNE post (you were right)). So, signed up again. Username ChrisBloom7 (tried to reuse xangelusx but it is still considered "taken"). Got through the registration process, got the emails, got activated, tried to login - bam-o, haiku-error land. Tried again, same thing. Clicked forgot password link, got the email, reset password (same as before), tried to log in again, same error. Me thinks there is something wrong with your login form. I typically use complex passwords (including at the least numbers and upper/lower-case letters, often a special character, almost always at least one space (in this case: numbers, upper/lowers and a space, 11 chars total)) so I wonder if that is the problem. I will try a "simple" password to see if that works, but thought you should know that I really loathe your registration system at this point.
Sardonically,
Chris BloomPS: BTW, your webmaster@ address, listed in emails and your website, is busted. Loathing turning to utter disdain.
Hi. This is the qmail-send program at xxx.xxx.com.
I'm afraid I wasn't able to deliver your message to the following addresses.
This is a permanent error; I've given up. Sorry it didn't work out.<webmaster AT mboffin.com>:
x.x.x.x does not like recipient.
Remote host said: 550 unknown user <webmaster AT mboffin.com>
Giving up on x.x.x.x.PPS: Your accounts@ email address is busted too. Utter disdain turning to passionate hatred
Hi. This is the qmail-send program at xxx.xxx.com.
I'm afraid I wasn't able to deliver your message to the following addresses.
This is a permanent error; I've given up. Sorry it didn't work out.<accounts AT mboffin.com>:
x.x.x.x does not like recipient.
Remote host said: 550 unknown user <accounts AT mboffin.com>
Giving up on x.x.x.x.PPS: Tried that "simple" password thing and still no dice. Passionate hatred turning to miming Darth Vader-esque jedi-choke thingy aimed your way.
Trackback address for this post
2 comments
It is in sore need of a total overhaul, and it's actually rather embarrassing that it's as bad as it is.
So why haven't I done anything about it? Well, I have. Sort of. Like I said, I've done a few re-writes, the latest of which is a Rails app. However, other projects keep intruding. Lately the project that's "intruding" is the next version of Earth Bridge (mboffin.com/earthbridge) which is in sore need of an update as well. It's getting downloaded hundreds of times a week and I can barely keep up with the e-mails I get about it. I've made a decision to stick with one project right now and get it DONE, so Earth Bridge is what I'm currently working on.
As soon as this next version of Earth Bridge is released, my next project IS my web site. It's been languishing too long and I really, really need to just get it done.
So how's that for an answer?
In the meantime, I can go ahead and do some back-end magic to get your account working. I'll let you know when your account is active.
(Oh, and I'm adding you to my reading list too.)
Leave a comment
| « Dear lurkers, stop lurking | Real Life vs. The Internet » |